After an accident in which my vehicle sustained damage exceeding 50% of its then current value, USAA Insurance Company offered me $140 for my Diminished Value claim.
I engaged Autoloss.com who prepared a comprehensive 15-page appraisal report of my vehicle both before and after the accident. Armed with this information, and advice from Monica at Autoloss.com, I was able to successfully negotiate a settlement of $5,000.
What is Diminished Value?
Know your rights if you've been in an auto accident. You may be entitled to a check from your insurance company for Diminished Value. Diminished value is the automatic loss in value from a collision. Almost every vehicle that has been in a wreck will have some form of inherent diminished value.
It has been estimated that 55% of consumers would not buy a car that had been in an accident. 81% would not have a car that had been in a wreck unless they were given a large discount. Our survey results show the stigma may be even higher.
Insurance companies generally do not acknowledge the right to recover diminished value!
In their online article (later removed from State Farm's website) "Diminished value fact or fiction?" State Farm has tried to discourage consumers from attempting to recover diminished value. We disagree. Many times claimants are not made aware of compensation for diminished value. Insurance companies would have you believe they are your advocates when in reality they are your adversaries. Many times insurance companies will reward their adjusters based on minimizing settlements. When a demand for diminished value is made, insurance companies may deny diminished value has happened. Some insurance companies give adjusters scripts to help them lower the value of claims. Claimants need to support their claims with an expert evaluation that diminished value has occurred.
Understanding Diminished Value Claims
Your one-year-old vehicle is worth $30,000. One day, you're hit by another car, causing $5,000 in damage. Your insurance company pays for the repairs.
Your newly repaired car is still worth, $30,000 right? Wrong. Although your body shop does an excellent job, and your vehicle looks as good as it did before the accident, it's now much less desirable having been in a collision, should you decide to sell it now, or down the road.
Many times a frame or structurally damaged vehicle cannot be sold as a "certified used vehicle." This will impact the vehicle's value by as much as 40%!
This is where diminished value comes in! Your insurance company will be quick to write you a check for the repairs, but you're entitled to diminished value.
If you list your vehicle for sale in the newspaper for $30,000, the first thing a buyer will ask is "Has the vehicle been in an accident?" Even if you didn't disclose the accident, the buyer could still look up the history using .
Once they discovered the accident, the buyer would no longer be willing to pay you $30,000, but instead might offer $22,000. In this case, the diminished value would be $8,000.
$30,000 before accident
-$22,000 sale price
$8,000 in diminished value!
Even if you've already settled with the insurance company on the body damage, you can still file a separate diminished value claim if the repairs were done recently.
Your claim for diminished value can be paid by your own insurance company or the other party's company.